HUNTER COLLEGE READING/WRITING CENTER
GRAMMAR AND MECHANICS
Sentence Structure: Relative Clauses


        A Relative Clause, also called an adjective clause, is a dependent clause that modifies a noun by making it more specific or adding additional information about it. A relative clause always contains a relative pronoun, which refers back to the noun it modifies.
        Relative clauses are extremely useful because they enable writers to be more specific and they make writing more sophisticated. At the same time, they are also very confusing to many writers--and not only students, either. The most common difficulties occur in understanding the different types of relative clauses, punctuating relatives, choosing the right pronoun, and agreement.


THE STRUCTURE OF RELATIVE CLAUSES

        Relative clauses are one kind of dependent clause, introduced by a relative pronoun that refers to the main noun the clause depends upon. A relative clause always immediately follows the noun it modifies. Like all clauses, relative clauses have a subject and a verb. The relative pronoun may be the subject of the clause, but it isnít always.

                      (Main noun)       (Rel. Pro)
I ate the ice cream that was in the freezer.
                                              (Subj)    (Verb)

                           (Main Noun)   (Rel. Pro)
I didnít eat the pie that you were saving for tonight.
                                                          (Subj)        (Verb)

        A relative pronoun is usually the first word of a relative clause; however, in some cases the pronoun follows a preposition:

        We have many blessings for which we are deeply grateful.

Additionally, when the relative pronoun is not the subject of the relative clause, it may be omitted entirely (especially in spoken English):

        I didnít eat the pie you were saving for tonight.

When the pronoun is the subject, it cannot be omitted:

        *I ate the ice cream was in the refrigerator.


TYPES OF RELATIVE CLAUSE

        There are two types of relative clause. Both types modify nouns, but the first type makes a noun more specific, while the second type adds extra facts or information about a noun. Itís important to understand these two types of relative clause because they not only differ in meaning, but they are punctuated differently and often use different relative pronouns.

Type 1--Clauses That Make Nouns Specific

        Women who work are happier than women who donít work.

        In the above sentence, the relative clauses who work and who donít work are used to make the noun women more specific. This type of relative clause changes the meaning of the noun it modifies.
        Women who work and women who donít work are two different groups of women. Without the appropriate relative clauses, this meaning would not be clear:

        *Women are happier than women.

This type of relative clause is sometimes called a Restrictive Relative Clause because it restricts or limits the meaning of a more general noun. Women who work is more restricted than the general noun women.

Here are some additional examples of sentences that show how a relative clause can change the meaning of a noun.

Students learn a lot.
Students who ask questions learn a lot.

Teachers are unpopular
Teachers who give a lot of assignments are unpopular.

Type 2--Clauses that Add Information

        Going to the movies, which I love to do, can be very expensive.

        In the above sentence, the relative clause which I love to do is used to say something extra about going to the movies, but it does not change the meaning of that phrase.
        If this clause were removed, the basic meaning of the sentence would be unchanged.

Going to the movies can be very expensive.

This type of clause is sometimes called an Unrestricted Relative Clause since the meaning of the noun it modifies is not restricted or limited by the clause.

Here are some more examples of relative clauses that add information. Note that although these clauses donít change the basic meaning of the sentences, they do make the sentences more detailed.

Hunter college is part of the City University of New York.
Hunter College, which is located at 68th and Park, is part of the City University of New York.

Creativity is a quality all human beings have.
Creativity, which may take many forms, is a quality all human beings have.


CHOOSING A RELATIVE PRONOUN

        The three most common relative pronouns are who, which, and that.
        The choice of pronoun depends upon the noun the clause refers to and on what type of relative clause is used.

Who

--refers to a person or people.
--may be used with a clause that makes a noun specific
--may be used with a clause that adds information

People who live in New York lead very busy lives.
My sister, who works for the YMCA, leads a very active life.

Which

--refers to a thing or concept
--is most often used in clauses that add information
--is sometimes used in a clause that makes a noun specific ( usually when a speaker or writer wants to sound more formal).

        The Empire State Building, which used to be the tallest building in the world, is still a popular tourist attraction.
        The lessons which we have learned are no more important than the lessons which we have yet to learn.

That

--is used only in clauses that make a noun more specific
--most often refers to a thing or concept
--is sometimes used to refer to a person or people, (usually only in informal writing or in speaking)

The book that you gave me is lost
The kid that I babysit threw your book in the trash.
        Note: Some people consider that inappropriate when referring to people although most writers and speakers use it quite naturally. If you wish to be formal, always use who for a person or people:

The child who threw your book away was only three years old.

Where and When

--are used for a clause that refers to a place or time
--may be used for clauses that make a noun more specific
--may be used for clauses that add information

        New York is a place where people of many different cultures live and work together.
        New York City, where millions of immigrants live, is sometimes called a Melting Pot.
        The 1960's was a time when many Americans began to question the actions of their government.
In the 1970's, when many new rights and freedoms had been gained, people began to lead quieter, more private lives.

Choosing between Who, Whom, and Whose

Like most pronouns in English,
ex. I
he
we
me
him
us
my
his
our

the relative pronoun who has more than one form

Who -- for the subject of a clause Whom--for the object of a verb or preposition Whose-- for a possessive noun

The form of who in a relative clause must change depending on whether itís the subject, object, or possessive.

As a Subject
        I know a woman who has two children.

In this sentence, who replaces woman as the subject of the verb has (A woman has two children)

As an Object
        My friend has two children, whom she loves very much.

In this sentence, whom replaces children as the object of the verb loves (She loves the children)

As a Possessive
        The older one is a boy, whose name is Jonathan

In this sentence whose replaces the noun boy as a possessive noun (the boyís name is Jonathan).

As an Object of a Preposition
        Jonathan has a little sister, with whom he plays all the time.

In this sentence, whom replaces the noun sister as the object of the preposition with (he plays with his sister).

        Note: In a standard sentence, the preposition and its object normally come after the verb, but because the relative pronoun always comes at the beginning of a relative clause, it is a convention to place the preposition at the beginning of a relative clause in formal writing, as in the example above. Often, however, when speaking or in informal writing, the preposition comes after the verb of a relative clause.

        Jonathan has a little sister, whom he plays with all the time.


PUNCTUATING RELATIVE CLAUSES

        Many people find it difficult to decide when to use a comma before a relative clause and when this is unnecessary, but the rule is really rather simple.
        If a relative clause defines or identifies the noun it modifies, no comma is required

The woman who is sitting next to me wants to ask a question.

In this sentence, the clause who is sitting next to me identifies a particular woman (the one sitting next to me).

        If the relative clause adds additional information or facts about the noun, then the clause must be set off from the rest of the sentence by commas:

        George Washington, who was the first president of the United States, is a symbol of honesty, bravery, and patriotism.

In this sentence, the noun George Washington is already identified (because itís a name). The relative clause who was the first president of the United States adds an additional piece of information about him, so it is set off with commas.

        Note: When a relative clause adding extra information comes between a subject and a verb, it must have commas both before and after it These commas indicate that the relative clause could be removed and the basic sentence would remain the same.


SUBJECT-VERB AGREEMENT IN RELATIVE CLAUSES

        Relative pronouns do not have different forms for singular or plural, but they replace both singular and plural nouns. The verb in a relative clause must agree with the subject. If the relative pronoun is the subject of the clause, then verb must agree with the noun that the pronoun replaces.

        I met a man who works for the FBI.

In this sentence who replaces the singular noun man, so the verb works has an -s ending.

        I have several friends who work at the United Nations.

In this sentence who replaces the plural noun friends so the verb work is in simple present tense.


RELATIVE CLAUSES AND SENTENCE STRUCTURE

        Since a relative clause is a dependent clause, the sentence it appears in must still have a main subject and a main verb besides the ones in the relative clause.
        Maintaining correct and consistent sentence structure in sentences with relative clauses is particularly tricky for several reasons. Since a relative clause always follows the noun it modifies, it can appear almost anywhere in a sentence that a noun can appear--in the subject, in the object, or in a prepositional phrase. This means that a relative clause often appears within a main clause, not separate from the main clause.
        When a relative clause appears in the subject or following the subject, it is placed between the main noun and verb of the main clause.

        People who have young children donít have much time for themselves.
        My parents, who live in Minneapolis, come to visit twice a year.

        When the relative clause comes between the main noun and verb of a sentence, it is easy to forget to finish the main clause by adding a main verb after using a relative clause. This results in a sentence fragment.

*My sister who went to school in Albany.

There are two ways to correct this kind of fragment.

  1. Add a main verb:
            My sister, who went to school in Albany, is a nurse.
  2. Remove the relative pronoun:
            My sister went to school in Albany.

    Another common mistake is to repeat the subject after the relative clause:

            *My sister, who went to school in Albany, she is a nurse.

This kind of sentence error can be corrected by omitting the second subject:

        My sister, who went to school in Albany, is a nurse.


Back to on-line resource file
Back to RWC home

Last updated Thursday, 18-July-02 05:23:00 EDT.
All pages Copyright © 1998 Hunter College Reading/Writing Center.
Please contact WebMaster with any questions or comments.