HUNTER COLLEGE READING/WRITING CENTER:
WRITING FOR ENGLISH COURSES
English 120: The Writing Portfolio
A portfolio for a writing class contains pieces of writing you
choose to be representative of your best work in that course.
During the semester, you will be required to submit two
portfolios--one midterm and one final. Each portfolio will be made
up of assignments you will have completed and previously handed in
to your teacher: an in-class essay, several take-home essays, with
and without drafts, and, in your final portfolio, a documented
paper.
You will be expected to use your own judgment as to which
pieces to include in your portfolios, but pay close attention to
your teacher's comments and those of your classmates for guidelines
and suggestions for revision. Consider your teacher in particular
as an editorial advisor rather than as a judge. That is why your
teacher will not be giving you grades for each piece of writing.
If you are concerned about your standing in terms of grades, ask
your teacher. He or she will be able to give you an overall
assessment of your work to that point.
Both your midterm and final portfolios will be assessed and
commented on by an independent reader, another teacher of the same
course. Your final grade will be given to you by your teacher in
consultation with that reader, and with one or more other readers
if there is any question about the level of work in your portfolio.
Your final portfolio is the major factor in determining your final
grade, but your work in class over the course of the semester is
important, too. Timely completion of assignments, participation in
class discussions, attendance, and the effort you put into group
work and peer editing with your classmates can make a critical
contribution to your grade in the course.
Midterm Portfolio
The midterm portfolio is primarily for practice and for giving
you an idea of your standing so far. For the midterm portfolio you
will need a manila folder to hold your work.
Your teacher will give you a midterm checklist which you should
attach to the inside left cover of your folder. (Your teacher may
give the folder, as well.) The list will provide a space for
comments by the reader on each of the items that must be included
in the portfolio:
|
Items
|
|
Comments
|
1. Cover letter
2. Finished essay with drafts
3. Finished essay without drafts
4. In-class essay
|
______
______
______
______
|
_____________________________________
_____________________________________
_____________________________________
_____________________________________
|
To select the pieces of writing you will include in the
portfolio, read all your work so far, and pick out the two at-home
essays you think are best. (You may revise them a little, but
don't make major changes without discussing them with your teacher
first.)
An important feature of the portfolio is that it not only
presents your finished work, but, in the case of one essay, it also
shows the process by which you arrived at the finished product, the
work you did to make that essay as good a piece of writing as it
is. The evidence of that process, that work, is the drafts you
wrote as you developed and revised your essay. The finished essay
with drafts can include drafts and notes all the way back to its
genesis, including your outline and any freewriting you may have
done (one student even included a napkin on which he had jotted an
idea while sitting in the cafeteria). The drafts should show
substantial revision, real development of ideas, not just extra
proofreading with a change in spelling here and there. (Since at
the beginning of the semester you do not know which essays you will
end up putting in your portfolio, you should keep the drafts you do
for all your essays. If you are using a computer, an easy way to
do this is to print hard copies of each draft or save drafts as
separate documents and then print at least two to hand in.)
Both finished essays should be typed, clean copies. For the
finished essay with drafts, the finished version should be placed
on top of the first draft, with the second draft following and any
notes, etc., underneath them.
In the same way you chose your at-home essays, pick out your
best in-class essay (if you have done more than one), but do not
revise or re-type it. Your in-class essay, like the drafts you
include with your finished essay, should be as they were originally
written, with any comments teachers or other students have written
on them.
Each item should be stapled (not paperclipped), clearly
labeled, and arranged in the order of the checklist. Exactness and
organization are important! *You will not be given a grade if your
portfolio is incomplete.*
When you are selecting pieces for your portfolio, you should
consider that variety is important as well as the quality of the
individual pieces. Avoid, if possible, including more than one
piece on the same topic, and include samples of different kinds of
writing.
Write your cover letter after you have selected the pieces of
writing to include in the portfolio. The purpose of the cover
letter is to give you an opportunity to explain the evolution of
your work--how you wrote it, why you chose it, etc.--to the reader
and perhaps influence that reader in your favor. It also gives you
a chance to reflect on the process of your writing and tells the
reader how you feel about it. The letter should be persuasive and
polished, like a cover letter for a resume or graduate school
application.
FINAL PORTFOLIO
Before the final portfolio is due, your teacher will give you
a folder with the final portfolio checklist. It will read as
follows:
Items Percentage of Total Grade
1. Cover letter ........ 5
2. Finished essay with drafts ........ 25
3. Documented paper ........ 30
4. Final exam ........ 15
5. Classwork ........ 25
______
Total ........ 100
|
Select your finished essay with drafts as you did for your
midterm portfolio. You should not include any item from your
midterm in your final portfolio unless you have your teacher's
permission, and then it must be significantly revised. Include
your documented paper (if you have written several in your section
of English 120, choose one). Your final portfolio will not be
returned, so if you want to keep any of the pieces in it, make
copies for yourself. Your teacher will insert your final exam into
the portfolio when you have finished it.
Your final portfolio will be collected a week before the last
class. Follow the same guidelines for neatness, organization and
drafts as you did for the midterm (see above). Your portfolio will
be kept on file with your teacher or the coordinator of the course
for one year in case you wish to appeal a grade.
Good writing takes care, checking on points you do not know,
obtaining feedback from readers, and revising as often as may be
necessary. Be careful and consistent. With a course like this it
is literally impossible to complete everything correctly if you
wait until the last minute. Good luck.
Back to on-line resource file
Back to RWC home
|